The ancient sacrifices and the ancient gods, they are all gone. Indra, who hindus believe is the god of rain and heaven, ate beef, according to the academic. Rigveda, manusmiriti sanction beefeating, the milli gazette, vol. Mukandilal writes in his book cow slaughter horns of a dilemma. Beef eating is all around us and if we dont eat it, we are viewed as extremely strange and forced to explain it every time. It can be clearly understood that spiritual part of vedas i. There was a time in this very india when, without eating beef, no brahmin could remain a brahmin. The myth of the holy cow by dn jha books the guardian. But this fact cannot be regarded as evidence that beefeating was condemned in the rigvedic period. Buddhist texts also lay down rules for meat eating by the monks. There is no beef eating in vedas aur animal slaughtering in vedas. Rigveda, manusmiriti sanction beefeating a recent photograph of some hindu protesters demanding a ban on nonvegetarian food in restaurants and government canteens in india made me sit up and take notice. Jan, 2012 to hear the answer, please click here answer summary. Rigveda, manusmiriti sanction beefeating a recent photograph of some hindu protesters demanding a ban on nonvegetarian food in restaurants and government canteens in.
Scholars have known for centuries that the ancient indians ate beef. The the earliest of the vedas, the rig veda, mentioned the consumption of meat offered in sacrifice at the altar, but even such ceremonial meateating was an exception, rather than a rule. From ramayana to the vedas, its clear india has a long history of. Thus in bhagavadgita ka personally speaks of gorak. Oct 10, 2015 there is no cow slaughter or beef eating in vedas or any classical hindu scriptures. A by mid2014 i had formed aa conclusivea view on this matter, summarised in the following statements. In the time of the oldest hindu sacred text, the rig veda c. From ramayana to the scriptures, its clear india has a long history of eating meat. Vegetarianism and meateating in 8 religions magazine web. Rigveda, manusmiriti sanction beefeating, the milli. Book excerpt read what ambedkar wrote on why brahmins started worshipping the cow and gave up eating beef it was a strategy, wrote the father of indian constitution, to vanquish buddhism. What do the hindu holy books say about eating meat. Is eating beef right as some vedas allow hindus to do.
Eating of meat and beef in the hindu tradition the hindu. The society in ancient india was based on four varnas, the term varna means character, quality or nature. Zakir naik and othes should read satyarth prakash and rig vedadi bhashya bhumika by swami dayanad sarswati and all their illusions about beef eating cow slaughter in hindu religion will vanish. I am from a family who are shakti worshippers and believe in advaita philosophy.
Vedas are replete with beef eating hindu gods, says india. I started this website in 2011 to compile and assessa the evidence for or against beef eating in ancient india. Killing a cow is also not allowed as it is considered as one of the biggest sins. Rigveda, manusmiriti sanction beefeating, the milli gazette. Apr 18, 2015 a ban on beef in india is not the answer. Many feel a moral obligation to shun the mentality of violence to which meat eating gives rise. Vedas are replete with beef eating hindu gods, says indias leading indologist rig veda says that indra, hindu god of rain and heaven, ate beef. Oct 05, 2015 there are ample evidences how the rgvedic people were fond of beefeating. Latest dadri beef kand has taken a communal riots shape. There are good books on vegetarianism, such as diet for a new america. Beef in vedas cow in vedic timeswhat vedas and scriptures speaks about eating beef. Even in funeral ceremony beefeating was considered an essential part. The rig veda, he said, mentions that indra asks to be served 15 to 20 cooked oxen.
Mar 24, 2011 but for this beef eating, a person who wants to read the verses in other way, or the way they are, its very clear that beef eating is in vedas. Others allowed only bulls or bullocks to be sent to the butcher. Featurefeaturefeaturefeature vegetarianism and meat eating in 8 religions while religions around the world share a quest for spirituality, they vary in their perception that respecting all forms of life is integral to that quest. Read what ambedkar wrote on why brahmins started worshipping. Vedon mein kahi bhi gau hatya ya kisi bhi pashu ki hatya ka koi pravdhan nahi hai. Dec 04, 2008 this also comes handy in convincing poor and illiterate indians to give up their faith on the grounds that their fundamental holy books the vedas contain all the inhuman elements like denigration of women, meateating, polygamy, casteism and above all beef eating.
Anyway, the validity of the slaughtering cow and bull in the hindu religion has become clear and obvious due to the evidences and ample proofs that have been presented in this article. Jan 20, 2016 this also comes handy in convincing poor and illiterate indians to give up their faith on the grounds that their fundamental holy books the vedas contain all the inhuman elements like denigration of women, meateating, polygamy, casteism and above all beef eating. The news is that some hindus murdered a muslim for slaughtering a cow. Some dharma texts composed in this same period insist that cows should not be eaten. Here youll find current best sellers in books, new releases in books, deals in books, kindle ebooks, audible audiobooks, and so much more. We do not know why hindu brothers insist on their rigid attitude. Hunting was a royal pastime, in which both men and women participated. Meat eating in hinduism and buddhism hindu website. Manusmriti chapter 5 verse 30 says, it is not sinful to eat meat of eatable. The vedas are also accused of animal sacrifice in sacrificial.
Before beef eating, lets first understand under what circumstances was meat allowed and which meat was allowed. Hindu law books prescribe rules for meat eating for the four castes and specify which type of meat is allowed for human consumption and under what circumstances. A scholar traces the history of beefeating in ancient india. Was beef eating common during the vedic times in india, and if yes. History is proof most hindus never had any beef with beef quartz. A mob in india just dragged a man from his home and beat. And we are witnessing that such incidents are increasing day by day after the ban has put on beef in some states. Seriously people pro beef will argue muh history of beef eating and their wrong interpretation of the vedas. Hindus are not allowed to eat beef because the cow is considered as the most sacred animal. After the fourth century bc, when the practice of vegetarianism spread throughout india among buddhists, jains and hindus, many hindus continued to eat beef.
Manu samhita is widely recognized as law book for hinduism. Beef eating in ancient india beef was widely eaten in. Heres the unpalatable truth about beef and hinduism. Apr 10, 2017 food and culture from ramayana to the scriptures, its clear india has a long history of eating meat the vedas refer to about 50 animals deemed fit for sacrifice and, by inference, for eating. November 9, 2010 one mans beef one mans beef pankaj mishra finds the roots of postpartition conflict in dn jhas account of indias sacred cows, the myth of the holy cow. The mantra states that in winter, the rays of sun get weakened and then get strong again in spring. On the whole, meateating is not completely forbidden. Vedic offerings primarily consisted of plant and dairy products, such as ghee, honey, soma an intoxicating plant juice, milk, yogurt and grain. Opinion a ban on beef in india is not the answer the new. Shortly before he died, at the age of 101, the anglobengali scholar and polemicist nirad chaudhuri received the leader of the hindu. The vedas refer to about 50 animals deemed fit for sacrifice.
Many gods such as indra and agni are described as having special preferences for different types of flesh indra had weakness for bulls meat and agni for bulls and cows. Premarital sex is not allowed for both males and females. A mob in india just dragged a man from his home and beat him to death for eating beef. Often times i hear indians and followers of the vedic path explain that meat eating is all right, that the vedic shastras do not condemn it. Many times there seems to be some confusion or lack of clarity on whether the vedic path condones or condemns the eating of meat. Read to debunk the myths of vedas having support of beefeating. Rig veda says that indra, hindu god of rain and heaven, ate beef. Does vedas allow animal killings or meat eating or voilance. Opinion a ban on beef in india is not the answer the. Also, comments of some great scholars of hinduism are also worth noting. There is no cow slaughter or beef eating in vedas or any.
First ever book dispelling myths about beef and animal sacrifice in hinduism. Like a doctor says to a patient with lung cancer, got due to smoking heavily more than 20 cigarette daily to smoke one cigarette per day and take the prescribed medication. Modern hindus forbidden from eating beef but ancient hindus. So this verse is not a legal prohibition from killing horses. Historically, all indian masses, including the brahmins, used to eat beef, both in what is called the vedic and the postvedic period. May 21, 2015 does vedas allow animal killings or meat eating or violence. Nov 29, 20 beef eating is all around us and if we dont eat it, we are viewed as extremely strange and forced to explain it every time.
Jul 12, 2002 the myth of the holy cow by dn jha 183pp, verso. Some hindus who did eat meat made a special exception and did not eat the meat of cow. There is no cow slaughter or beef eating in vedas or any classical hindu scriptures. Heres the unpalatable truth about beef and hinduism the present controversy around beef eating, accompanied by violent objection and equally aggressive support, is engineered by extremist. One may eat meat when it has been sprinkled with water, while mantras were recited, when brahmanas desire ones doing it, when one is engaged in the performance of a rite according to the law, and when ones life is in danger.
There is also a fine magazine called vegetarian times. Dec 17, 20 what the scriptures say about hindus eating meat. Hinduism and its complicated history with cows and people who eat. Why should beefeating give rise to untouchability at a later stage. Dec 11, 20 as a person born in a hindu family i have been raised since childhood with the teaching that eating beef is not allowed in hinduism. The theme is an evergreen song within the context of popular level of viewing at indian spiritual tradition. That is why for those who are addicted to meat eating, meat eating is allowed under certain restricted. Rigveda 1085 declares, on the occasion of a girls marriage oxen and cows are slaughtered. Hinduism and its complicated history with cows and people.
Modern hindus forbidden from eating beef but ancient. One may also question that as yajnas were rituals, one cant say that the consumption of the flesh of cow and other milch animals was a common practice among the people in vedic india. Vegetarianism is their recommendation, as seen from the verses below, but meat eating is their concession. Today in america and europe millions of people are vegetarians because they want to live a long time and be healthy. October 28, 2010 proofs that beef was eaten by ancient hindus and is eaten by many hindus today. I would like to know from the members here in this forum, why is eating beef prohibited in hinduism. One who partakes of human flesh, the flesh of a horse or of another animal, and deprives others of milk by slaughtering cows, o king, if such a fiend does not desist by other means, then you should not hesitate to cut off his head. The earth assumed the form of a cow and begged him to spare her life. Quotes that disapprove, even denounce, meateating rig veda.
However, if the discussion is about practical spirituality, then the issue is not if eating the beef is right or not. Beef in vedascow in vedic timeswhat vedas and scriptures. Beef eating in vedas and other hindu texts truth about hinduism. As far as eating beef is concerned, however, it is strictly prohibited to everyone. But there is no more brahmin supermacy in this world and i find it amazing that people still think they are somehow sticking it up to the supreme caste by eating beef.
Jul 30, 2017 public domain in this poster condemning the consumption of beef, the sacred cow kamadhenu is depicted as containing various deities within her body. Vedas are replete with beef eating hindu gods, says indias. Heres what vedas say on killing cows the problem lies with the inability to interpret the ancient texts in the correct sense. Holiness of the cow and controversy over beefeating in ancient india a sampling of scholarship suggests both ancient indian texts and rulers adopted a mixed approach condoning as well as prohibiting the killing and consumption of cows, depending on circumstances. This answer discusses about the eating of meats and when it is allowed to eat. Jul 25, 2010 however they may differ from each other in india, in that they are all one they never eat beef. Adultery is not allowed for both males and females.
927 1126 1327 367 441 68 169 1089 746 802 575 333 184 750 1375 1317 886 1338 856 773 158 359 1093 473 812 1491 1434 1229 395 404 888 1135 764 955 1427 137 1207 1506 835 1255 1430 374 185 560 55 536